Skip to content
Florin logoflorinCall or text(408) 444-7192

Comparison

State Farm vs Progressive for business auto insurance

Shaurya Aggarwal 7 min read

Commercial auto share, 2025
Progressive 13.20% (1st); State Farm 3.15% (6th), per the NAIC
How you buy
State Farm: local agent; Progressive: online, phone or agent
Published price
Progressive: $207 a month median per vehicle, 2025
Telematics
Progressive: 5% to enroll; State Farm: one-time decrease
Federal filings
Progressive files BMC-91X and MCS-90; State Farm lists none

State Farm and Progressive are the two largest private passenger auto insurers in the US, but they handle business vehicles very differently. This page compares how each sells business auto, the vehicles and coverages it lists, its telematics program and published prices, based on each company’s own pages as of November 2026.

How each one works

State Farm sells commercial auto as part of a small business lineup it says it has offered since 1935. You can start a quote online with a ZIP code or ask an agent to contact you, and a local State Farm agent builds the policy. State Farm’s disclosures name State Farm Mutual Automobile Insurance Company, State Farm Fire and Casualty Company and other group companies as the insurers.

Progressive Commercial is Progressive’s business arm, and its auto policies come from Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates. It sells by phone, online and through independent agents and says it insures commercial vehicles in all 50 states but not Washington, D.C.

The NAIC’s 2025 market share report puts the two nearly level in personal auto, at 18.64% and 18.60%, but far apart in commercial auto: Progressive ranks first with about $10.18 billion in direct premiums written and a 13.20% share, State Farm sixth with about $2.43 billion and 3.15%. AM Best’s 2026 rankings also name Progressive the largest US commercial auto writer for 2025.

State Farm and Progressive side by side

The table sums up the facts each company publishes about its business auto offering.

Based on State Farm and Progressive Commercial websites and the NAIC 2025 market share report, as of November 2026
AspectState FarmProgressive
Who issues the policyState Farm group companiesProgressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates
How you buyStart online with a ZIP code; an agent completes itOnline, by phone or through an independent agent
Where it sellsThrough agents; options vary by stateAll 50 states, not Washington, D.C.
Vehicles namedCars, pickups, vans, box trucks, flatbeds, farm vehiclesBusiness autos, trucks up to tractor-trailers, trailers
Federal filingsNot mentioned on its commercial auto pageBMC-91X and MCS-90 in all states
TelematicsDrive Safe & Save BusinessSnapshot ProView; Smart Haul for ELD trucks
Published pricesNone$207 a month median per vehicle, business auto (2025)
2025 commercial auto share3.15%, ranked 6th (NAIC)13.20%, ranked 1st (NAIC)

Coverage differences

Both list the same core coverages: liability, medical payments, collision, comprehensive and uninsured and underinsured motorist. The differences are in the vehicles and operations each one describes and in the extras around the auto policy.

  • Vehicles: State Farm names cars, pickups, box trucks, flatbeds, farm vehicles and vans. Progressive names company cars, light trucks, SUVs, vans, trucks up to tractor-trailers and commercial trailers.
  • Business types: State Farm says it often covers artisan and service contractors, farmers and ranchers, florists and caterers. Progressive lists contractors, delivery companies, livery, pizza delivery, food trucks, caterers, nonprofits and churches.
  • Filings: Progressive lists BMC-91X and MCS-90 filings in all states, Form E and Form H for intrastate haulers and tow filings in Colorado, Montana, Oklahoma and Texas. State Farm’s commercial auto page does not mention filings.
  • Employee and rented vehicles: State Farm offers employers’ non-owned and hired car coverage, with availability varying by state. Progressive says hired and non-owned auto can be added to a commercial auto, general liability or BOP policy.
  • Tools: both point to inland marine for loose tools. Progressive says permanently attached equipment such as ladder racks falls under the auto policy.
  • Fleets: Progressive describes fleet policies for 10 or more vehicles, with large fleets handled by Progressive Fleet & Specialty Programs.

Prices, discounts and telematics

Progressive publishes its own customer data. For new 2025 policies with clean driving records, it reports a median of $207 a month and an average of $276 per vehicle for business auto customers such as cleaning services, restaurants and shops, and a median of $203 and an average of $260 for contractors. The figures cover liability and physical damage and exclude for-hire trucks and tow trucks.

State Farm does not publish commercial auto prices. Its FAQ says the number of vehicles, their value, how much they are driven and your industry decide what you pay, so the only way to get a State Farm figure is a quote from an agent.

Both offer telematics for business vehicles, and they work differently. Leaving State Farm’s program triggers a post-program premium adjustment, up or down, for at least another year. Progressive says Snapshot ProView is not available in all states.

Telematics programs, per State Farm and Progressive Commercial program pages, November 2026
AspectState Farm Drive Safe & Save BusinessProgressive Snapshot ProView
DeviceBluetooth beacon per vehicle, plus appPlug-in device in each vehicle’s diagnostic port
Savings to startOne-time participation decrease per vehicle5% at enrollment; new customers average 9%
At renewalPremium may rise, fall or stay the sameCould save 8% to 20%, per Progressive
EligibilityBased on weight, body type and useAll commercial auto except trucks with ELDs
Fleet toolsPortal with near real-time location, trip maps, driver scoresFull tools at 3 or more vehicles; monthly scorecards for 1 or 2

Who each tends to fit

Based on what each company describes, the fit depends on your vehicles, your operation and how you like to buy.

If you haul for hire across state lines, ask a State Farm agent whether your operation qualifies before planning around its quote.

  • State Farm may suit a local business running cars, pickups, vans or light trucks, such as a contractor, florist, caterer, farm or ranch, that wants a named local agent.
  • State Farm may also suit an employer whose staff run errands in their own cars, through its non-owned and hired car coverage.
  • Progressive may suit an owner who wants to quote and manage the policy online or by phone.
  • Progressive may suit for-hire carriers, tow operators and intrastate haulers that need filings, and businesses running heavy trucks, trailers, livery or food trucks.

Buying, service and claims

With State Farm, your agent handles quotes, changes and coverage questions, and Drive Safe & Save Business enrollment also goes through the agent. Customers can see all business accounts with one login and create a certificate of insurance online.

Progressive lists 24/7 policy service by phone or online, flexible billing, commercial claims adjusters and network repair shops nationwide, plus a truck repair network for truck customers. It also states that prices vary based on how you buy, so a direct quote and an independent agent’s quote can differ.

If you bundle other lines, check who issues each one. Progressive says its BOP, general liability, workers’ comp and other business policies come from affiliated and unaffiliated insurers through Progressive Advantage Agency, and each insurer handles its own claims.

Why comparing several quotes matters

A State Farm agent quotes State Farm policies and Progressive quotes its own, so each gives you one insurer’s view of your vehicles and drivers. The NAIC counts about $77.1 billion in US commercial auto premiums for 2025, and the top 25 groups held only about 67% of it.

Ask for the same liability limit, deductibles, radius, listed drivers and add-ons such as hired and non-owned auto on every quote so you compare like with like. A broker such as Florin can compare quotes from several insurers alongside the ones you get from State Farm and Progressive.

Frequently asked questions

Does State Farm insure semi trucks or for-hire trucking?

State Farm’s commercial auto page lists cars, pickups, vans, box trucks, flatbeds and farm vehicles and does not mention federal filings such as the BMC-91X, so ask an agent whether your operation qualifies. Progressive says it insures trucks up to tractor-trailers and files the BMC-91X and MCS-90.

What is the difference between business auto and commercial auto insurance?

State Farm says business auto generally refers to private passenger vehicles used mainly for business, while commercial auto covers trucks and utility vehicles that carry goods or are built for a business purpose.

How much does Progressive business auto insurance cost?

Progressive reports a median of $207 a month and an average of $276 per vehicle for new 2025 business auto policies with clean records, and a median of $203 for contractors. Your price depends on vehicles, drivers, location, limits and claims history.

Can I get a telematics discount on business vehicles?

Progressive gives 5% for enrolling in Snapshot ProView, where offered. State Farm gives a one-time decrease per vehicle enrolled in Drive Safe & Save Business, and the renewal adjustment can go up or down.

Does commercial auto cover tools in my truck?

Usually not. Both insurers say loose tools are typically covered by inland marine, while Progressive says permanently attached items such as ladder racks fall under the auto policy.

Facts are drawn from the providers’ own published information and other cited sources as of the date above, and may change. Florin is an independent brokerage; this page is not an endorsement or a rating of any insurer.

← All provider reviews