Provider profile
Coterie Insurance review: BOP, liability and claims
- What it is
- Tech-enabled managing general agent (MGA) and licensed agency
- Who issues policies
- Partner carriers incl. Spinnaker, Clear Spring, Benchmark and Everspan
- Main lines
- BOP, general liability, professional liability; cyber, EPLI add-ons
- Where it sells
- BOP and GL in all 50 states, through licensed agents and partners
- Not written
- Workers’ comp and commercial auto, per Coterie’s claims page
- Founded
- 2018; headquartered in Appleton, Wisconsin
This review explains what Coterie is, who actually issues its policies, what it covers and for whom, and how claims work, based on Coterie’s own published pages as of November 2026. It is a factual profile, not a rating.
What Coterie is and how buying works
Coterie says it launched in 2018 to use data and technology to simplify small business insurance for agents, brokers and policyholders. Its press releases describe it as a tech-enabled, data-powered managing general agent (MGA) for small business property and casualty coverage, and its insurance agency is licensed in Wisconsin (national producer number 19000811). Its headquarters is in Appleton, Wisconsin.
You generally do not buy from Coterie directly. Its product pages send small business owners to a “Find an Agent” page, and its about page urges businesses to work with a licensed insurance professional. Agents, brokers and partner platforms quote and bind through Coterie’s system, which Coterie says pre-fills business details from public data, detects the business’s 6-digit NAICS code and returns a bindable quote in under 90 seconds.
Coterie is privately held. Its about page lists investors including The Hartford, Intact, Weatherford Capital and Alpha Edison, and its 2025 year-in-review release says it received a strategic investment from Allianz X. In that same December 2025 release, Coterie reported more than $200 million in direct written premium and more than 100,000 policies in force.
Who issues the policy
Because Coterie is an MGA, the insurer on your declarations page will be one of its carrier partners. Coterie’s agent download page lists five insurers with their NAIC codes, and the one named on your quote is the company that pays claims.
Most Coterie policies are admitted, meaning the carrier files its rates and forms with your state. Coterie’s claims page also mentions surplus lines policies, identified by a policy number starting with “CSE” and the carrier “Spinnaker Specialty”. Surplus lines policies generally are not backed by state guaranty funds, so check which type you are being offered.
| Carrier | NAIC code |
|---|---|
| Spinnaker Insurance Company | 24376 |
| Clear Spring Property and Casualty Insurance Company | 15563 |
| Benchmark Insurance Company | 41394 |
| Everspan Insurance Company | 24961 |
| Providence Washington Insurance Company | 24295 |
Coverage it offers and for whom
Coterie’s core products are a business owner’s policy, standalone general liability and miscellaneous professional liability (errors and omissions). It has added cyber, workplace violence and employment practices liability, which are sold alongside a BOP or general liability policy. Coterie says its BOP and professional liability can be paid monthly or annually.
| Product | What it includes | Availability |
|---|---|---|
| Business owner’s policy | General liability, commercial property and business income | All 50 states (admitted) |
| General liability | Third-party bodily injury and property damage | All 50 states (admitted) |
| Professional liability | Errors, negligence and missed contractual promises | Most states |
| EPLI | Endorsement to a BOP or GL policy | Nationwide except CA, DC, MD, NY and WY (Dec. 2025) |
| Cyber and workplace violence | Coverage added to the platform alongside BOP or GL | Eligible classes; ask your agent |
Eligibility limits and lines Coterie does not write
As of November 2026, Coterie’s BOP page lists eligibility of 50 or fewer employees and $10 million or less in annual revenue, with lower caps for contractors: 15 employees and $5 million. Coterie’s January 2026 agent guide describes the BOP limits differently, as up to 100 employees and revenue generally up to $5 million depending on class, so confirm the current rule for your class with your agent.
The same BOP page says higher-risk operations such as heavy manufacturing, large-scale food production or businesses with extensive commercial auto exposure may not qualify for a standard BOP. Coterie says its system has appetite for more than 80% of small business classes and flags ineligible businesses at the start of the quote.
Coterie’s claims page states that it does not write workers’ compensation or automobile policies, and that its policies do not cover warranty of work, such as a painter using the wrong color on a client’s walls.
Who it suits and who it may not
Based on its published appetite, Coterie is built for Main Street businesses that need a BOP or general liability policy quickly: offices, retail shops, restaurants, service providers, home-based businesses and smaller contractors within the size caps. Coterie says certificates of insurance are available immediately after a policy is issued, with unlimited certificates at no additional cost, which matters if a landlord or general contractor needs proof before you start.
It is a partial answer for businesses whose main exposure is on the road or on the payroll. Truckers, couriers, delivery services and contractors with crews or work vehicles will still need commercial auto and, in most states, workers’ comp from another insurer. Businesses above the employee or revenue caps, and those wanting EPLI in California, DC, Maryland, New York or Wyoming, will also need to look elsewhere.
How claims and service work
Policyholders report standard claims online through Coterie’s policyholder portal, with a separate option for surplus lines policies, or by phone at 1-855-680-2440 from 8am to 5pm ET. Agents, attorneys and third parties use an online claim form. Coterie says you can expect to hear from it within 3 to 5 business days, when an adjuster is assigned.
Cyber claims are reported to Coterie and investigated with its partner Cyberscout, and workplace violence claims are handled by a specialist partner. Coterie also takes loss run requests through its claims page, and during 2025 it launched an upgraded chat assistant called Coty for policyholder and partner support.
- Policy number
- Name of the person or business insured
- Date of the loss
- Description of the event
- Carrier name
What to compare and ask before buying
Coterie does not publish typical prices on the pages reviewed here, so the quote itself is your best guide. Ask these questions before you bind.
- Which carrier issues the policy, and is it admitted or surplus lines in your state?
- Does your class and size fit the current BOP caps, especially if you are a contractor?
- What are the per-occurrence and aggregate limits, deductibles and property values?
- Are additional insured, waiver of subrogation or primary wording available for your contracts?
- Is professional liability, EPLI or cyber available in your state for your class?
- Where will you get commercial auto and workers’ comp, since Coterie does not write them?
How it fits with getting several quotes
Coterie quotes are only available through agents and partners, and they cover the liability and property side of a small business. Comparing its BOP or general liability quote with other insurers’ on the same limits, deductibles and endorsements shows whether its price and terms fit your business.
If you also need commercial auto or workers’ comp, quoting the whole package at once avoids gaps between policies. A broker such as Florin can compare quotes from several insurers for the lines you need.
Frequently asked questions
Is Coterie a real insurance company?
Coterie is a managing general agent and a licensed insurance agency (national producer number 19000811), not the insurer itself. Policies are issued by carriers it lists, such as Spinnaker Insurance Company and Clear Spring Property and Casualty Insurance Company.
Can I buy Coterie insurance directly online?
Generally not. Coterie’s product pages direct small business owners to its Find an Agent page, and policies are quoted and bound by licensed agents, brokers or partner platforms.
Does Coterie offer workers’ comp or commercial auto?
No. Coterie’s claims page says it does not write workers’ compensation or automobile policies, so those claims and policies go to another insurer.
How do I file a claim with Coterie?
Report it online through the policyholder portal or call 1-855-680-2440 from 8am to 5pm ET with your policy number, carrier name, date and description of the loss. Coterie says to expect contact within 3 to 5 business days.
Can I get a certificate of insurance from Coterie?
Yes. Coterie says certificates are available immediately after the policy is issued, with unlimited certificates at no additional cost.
Can I pay for a Coterie policy monthly?
Coterie says its BOP and professional liability policies can be purchased on a monthly or annual basis. Your agent can confirm the options on your quote.
Facts are drawn from the providers’ own published information and other cited sources as of the date above, and may change. Florin is an independent brokerage; this page is not an endorsement or a rating of any insurer.