Provider profile
AmTrust review: workers’ comp, BOP, auto and claims
- What it is
- Insurance carrier group selling through appointed independent agents
- Who issues policies
- Affiliates such as Technology Insurance Company and Wesco Insurance Company
- Main lines
- Workers’ comp, BOP, package, general liability, cyber, EPLI
- Commercial auto
- Add-on only, $300,000 to $1 million combined single limit
- AM Best rating
- A- (Excellent), outlook positive, affirmed October 2026
- Founded
- 1998 in New York; privately held since November 2018
This review covers who AmTrust is, who issues its policies, the small business lines it writes and the eligibility, payment and claims rules it publishes, based on AmTrust’s own pages and filings as of November 2026.
What AmTrust is and how buying works
AmTrust Financial Services was founded in downtown Manhattan in 1998 by George and Michael Karfunkel and Barry Zyskind, according to its company history. It entered the small business workers’ comp market in the early 2000s, and AmTrust says the NAIC designated it the third-largest writer of workers’ comp in the US in 2021 and 2022.
AmTrust went private on November 29, 2018. Its SEC filing that day says an entity formed by funds managed by Stone Point Capital, together with the Karfunkel-Zyskind family, acquired the roughly 45% of shares the family did not already own or control, valuing the company’s equity at about $2.95 billion.
Policies are issued by affiliated carriers, not the holding company. AmTrust says Technology Insurance Company writes monoline workers’ comp for small and mid-size businesses and AmTrust Insurance Company writes workers’ comp and commercial package coverage. Business placed through wholesale agents can be written on a non-admitted basis by Security National Insurance Company or Associated Industries Insurance Company.
You cannot buy an AmTrust policy online yourself. Its small business pages send owners to a form that collects state, coverage and years in business, and quotes come through AmTrust-appointed agents.
Coverage it offers and for whom
Workers’ comp is the core line. AmTrust’s BOP is aimed at businesses with fewer than 50 employees and lists professional offices, services, contractors, retail, restaurants, wholesale and apartment or condo risks among its classes. AmTrust says it offers agents a 10% discount on a bundled BOP for its workers’ comp policyholders in targeted classes.
For contractors, AmTrust says coverage can be written as a BOP, a package or monoline policies. Its Artisan Contractor Risk Report, based on 26,000 workers’ comp claims over 10 years, found ladder falls and lifting strains were the most common injuries.
| Line | What AmTrust publishes |
|---|---|
| Workers’ comp | Monoline or bundled; large deductible and excess options for bigger accounts |
| Business owner’s policy | General liability, property and business interruption; add crime, cyber and more |
| Commercial package and general liability | Listed small business products |
| Commercial auto | Add-on to another AmTrust policy; $300,000 to $1 million CSL |
| Cyber, EPLI and executive liability | Listed products with their own claim reporting |
Commercial auto limits and excluded operations
AmTrust does not write commercial auto as a monoline policy; it is added to a BOP, workers’ comp, general liability or package policy. According to its commercial auto page, it covers light, medium and heavy vehicles within a local and intermediate radius, with liability limits from $300,000 to $1 million combined single limit. Preferred risks include trade contractors such as electricians, HVAC, landscapers, plumbers and roofers, plus auto parts, beverage and food distributors.
AmTrust lists these operations as generally ineligible for its commercial auto coverage:
For for-hire trucking, The Insurer reported on January 20, 2026 that AmTrust is moving its commercial trucking business to a newly formed managing general agency, ANV Transportation, part of the ANV Group platform launched with Blackstone Credit & Insurance. If you run a motor carrier, ask your agent which entity now quotes the risk and which carrier’s name is on the policy.
- Hauling: car haulers, dump truck operations, iron and steel hauling, livestock hauling, LPG transport and mobile home transport
- Towing: tow truck operations, wreckers and winching or boom operations
- Passengers and emergency: ambulances, livery, para transit, emergency vehicles and fire departments
- Delivery and waste: fast food delivery and garbage collection
- Heavy work: building wrecking, heavy equipment movers, pipeline contractors, street and road contractors and softwood loggers
Workers’ comp fit and payment options
AmTrust publishes the profile it typically looks for in workers’ comp accounts. These are guidelines, and the underwriter makes the final call.
Standard payment plans on AmTrust’s payments page run from pay in full to 10 or 12 monthly installments, with 12 installments available only on AutoPay, which requires a minimum premium of $600. AmTrust also offers PAYO, which bills workers’ comp each pay period based on actual payroll through an approved payroll company or self-reporting, with no upfront money to bind and no AmTrust processing fees, according to its PAYO page.
- At least one full-time employee in addition to the owners
- Fewer than 75 employees at a single location at the same time
- At least 1 year of prior workers’ comp coverage, with loss runs
- 3 years of prior coverage for artisan contractors, though AmTrust says it will consider contractors without it
Who it suits and who it may not
Based on AmTrust’s published appetite, it lines up with small employers that have staff on payroll and a workers’ comp history, especially nonprofits, retail and restaurants, which its agent page names as areas of emphasis. Trade contractors who want workers’ comp, a BOP and a few work vehicles with one carrier match its auto preferred list.
It may not fit an owner with no employees or a business that only needs commercial auto. Operations on the ineligible auto list, fleets needing more than $1 million of auto liability without separate excess and owners who want to buy online without an agent are also outside what AmTrust describes.
How claims and service work
AmTrust uses one claims number, 844-451-0750, for workers’ comp, property, auto and general liability claims. Workers’ comp, property and auto claims can also be filed online through AmTrust Access with your policy number and ZIP code, which returns a claim number immediately.
For workplace injuries, AmTrust offers AmCares, a 24/7 nurse line at no extra cost that triages the injury and points the worker to in-network care. AmTrust asks policyholders to report every injury promptly, even without full details.
Cyber claims go to a separate line, 877-207-1047, and professional and management liability claims must be submitted in writing by email. AmTrust says its claims adjusters average more than 20 years of experience.
What to compare and ask before buying
AmTrust does not publish prices. It says workers’ comp cost depends on the number of employees, annual payroll, occupation and rate classification, and that a premium audit sets the final premium. These questions help when an agent brings you an AmTrust quote:
- Which AmTrust company issues the policy, and is it admitted or non-admitted in your state
- Whether your class qualifies for the 10% BOP discount when bundled with workers’ comp
- Whether a $1 million auto limit meets your contracts, and how any excess would be written
- Which payment plan you qualify for, and whether your payroll company works with PAYO
- How payroll is estimated, so the year-end audit does not produce a large bill
How it fits with getting several quotes
Because AmTrust sells only through appointed agents and auto must sit on another AmTrust policy, its quote often arrives as a bundle. Compare it line by line against other carriers at the same limits, class codes and payment terms.
A broker such as Florin can compare quotes from several insurers, so you can see how an AmTrust bundle compares with a separate auto or trucking carrier.
Frequently asked questions
Is AmTrust a legitimate insurance company?
Yes. AmTrust Financial Services was founded in 1998 and its policies are issued by licensed affiliates such as Wesco Insurance Company, which AmTrust says is licensed in all 50 states and DC. Insurance Journal reported that AM Best affirmed the group’s A- (Excellent) rating in October 2026.
Can I buy AmTrust insurance directly online?
No. AmTrust sells small business coverage through appointed independent agents; its website quote form starts that process.
Does AmTrust sell commercial auto on its own?
No. AmTrust says it does not offer monoline commercial auto; it must be added to an AmTrust BOP, workers’ comp, general liability or package policy, with liability limits from $300,000 to $1 million.
Does AmTrust insure dump trucks or tow trucks?
Generally not under its small business auto program. AmTrust lists dump truck operations, tow truck operations, wreckers and car haulers among ineligible exposures.
What is the AmTrust claims phone number?
AmTrust lists 844-451-0750 for workers’ comp, property, auto and general liability claims and 877-207-1047 for cyber claims.
Who owns AmTrust?
AmTrust has been privately held since November 2018, when, according to its SEC filing, an entity formed by funds managed by Stone Point Capital, together with the Karfunkel-Zyskind family, acquired the public shares.
Facts are drawn from the providers’ own published information and other cited sources as of the date above, and may change. Florin is an independent brokerage; this page is not an endorsement or a rating of any insurer.