Skip to content
Florin logoflorinCall or text(408) 444-7192

Provider profile

Acuity Insurance review: trucking, contractors and claims

Shaurya Aggarwal 7 min read

What it is
Mutual insurance carrier owned by its policyholders
Who issues policies
Acuity, A Mutual Insurance Company (Texas personal auto excepted)
Founded
1925 in Sheboygan County, Wisconsin, per the Wisconsin OCI
Where it sells
Licensed in 38 states as of the 2025 OCI report; not CA, FL or NY
How you buy
Through independent agents; quotes can be started on acuity.com
Largest line
Commercial auto, mostly trucking, per the Wisconsin OCI

This review explains what Acuity is, how you buy a policy, what it offers truckers, contractors and small businesses and how claims work. It draws on Acuity’s own pages and its most recent state examination report, and it does not rate or rank the insurer.

What Acuity is and how buying works

Acuity, A Mutual Insurance Company, started on September 25, 1925, as the Mutual Automobile Insurance Company of the Town of Herman. That is according to the Wisconsin OCI’s examination report, which was dated October 24, 2025, and covers the company as of December 31, 2024. It was later called Heritage Mutual and became Acuity in March 2001. As a mutual, it is owned by its policyholders, not by stockholders.

The OCI reports that about 75% of Acuity’s business is commercial and 25% personal. It wrote about $3.1 billion of direct premium in 2024, with Wisconsin the largest state at 20.1%. In a February 2026 press release, Acuity said it ended 2025 with more than 400,000 policyholders. Its site says it insured more than 167,000 businesses as of January 31, 2026.

Most policies are sold by independent agents, who can also quote other insurers. Acuity’s home page says it works with more than 30,000 of them. You can start a business quote on Acuity’s website or use its agent finder. The OCI also notes a digital agency subsidiary, Acuity Advantage Insurance Agency, that either sells Acuity products directly or refers customers to other carriers.

Coverage it offers and for whom

Acuity’s business coverage page covers general liability, property, commercial auto, workers’ comp, the Bis-Pak business owner’s policy and commercial package policies. It also lists excess liability, inland marine, cyber, crime and fidelity, equipment breakdown and employment-related practices liability. Its industry pages cover construction, manufacturing, retail, restaurants, wholesale, trucking, service businesses, auto repair, landlords and offices.

Contractors get extra options. Acuity’s contractor page lists property in the course of construction, contractors’ equipment, contractors’ errors and omissions, voluntary property damage, installation and builders’ risk. It also offers what it calls an extensive portfolio of additional insured endorsements. Acuity insureds get OSHA 10-hour training at no cost.

Selected business lines and options, from Acuity’s coverage pages (November 2026)
LineWhat Acuity lists
Commercial autoLiability, physical damage, med pay, PIP where available, UM/UIM
Auto optionsAuto Enhancements, non-owned vehicles, towing, business income
Bis-Pak (BOP)Building, contents, liability, business income included
ContractorsBuilders’ risk, equipment, E&O, additional insured forms
Other linesWorkers’ comp, excess liability, cyber, crime, ERPL

Trucking coverage and motor carrier filings

Trucking is central to Acuity’s business. The OCI reports that commercial auto is the company’s largest line and that most of it is trucking-related. Acuity’s company profile says it insures about 300,000 commercial vehicles. Its trucking page says it insures both owner-operators and large fleets, and that it has insured truckers for more than 40 years.

The trucking page lists commercial auto, cargo, workers’ comp, general liability and excess liability. It also lists several specialized coverages:

  • Deadhead or bobtail coverage for owner-operators driving without a trailer or with an empty one
  • Trailer interchange for non-owned trailers you are responsible for under contract
  • Truckers’ enhancements, more than 20 coverages including a combined truck/trailer/cargo deductible, loan/lease gap, rental reimbursement and towing after a loss
  • Federal and state motor carrier filings, including financial responsibility and cargo filings
  • A motor carrier toolbox aimed at CSA and FMCSA compliance, plus loss control staff

Who it suits and who it may not

Based on its published appetite, Acuity is aimed at trucking operations of any size, contractors and Main Street businesses such as retailers, restaurants, wholesalers and auto repair shops. On the trucking side, Acuity names common carriers, milk haulers, sand and gravel haulers, flatbeds and refrigerated freight.

Location matters most. The 2025 OCI report lists Acuity as licensed in Alabama, Arizona, Arkansas, Colorado, Delaware, Georgia, Idaho, Illinois, Indiana, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Maine, Maryland, Michigan, Minnesota, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, Oregon, Pennsylvania, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, Vermont, Virginia, Washington, West Virginia, Wisconsin and Wyoming. The same report says that in August and September 2025 Acuity told regulators it would withdraw from personal and commercial lines in Nevada.

A business based in a state that is not listed, such as California, Florida or New York, will need another insurer. The business coverage list on Acuity’s site also has no standalone professional liability policy for consultants or other professional firms. If you want to buy and manage everything online without an agent, check whether that option exists in your state.

How claims and service work

Acuity’s claims page says you can report a claim online or by phone at 800-242-7666, 24 hours a day, including weekends and holidays. Your agent or the Acuity app can also report it. Acuity says one claims professional handles your claim from start to finish. It aims to contact you the same business day or within 24 hours of the report.

Emergency roadside assistance is available 24/7 at 866-732-1466 and can be added to any policy that includes a vehicle. Acuity keeps a preapproved list of repair shops whose repairs are guaranteed by the shop, and it offers a nurse helpline for nonemergency employee injuries. Its app holds digital certificates of insurance and vehicle ID cards. Acuity notes that the app ID card does not satisfy proof-of-insurance rules in some states.

What to compare and ask before buying

Coverage details and prices depend on your state, operations, driving records and loss history. Acuity says its features depend on underwriting and are not available in every state. Ask the agent these questions before you sign:

  • Does Acuity write my line of business in my state, and is a Bis-Pak available to me?
  • For trucking, which filings will Acuity make, and are bobtail, trailer interchange and the truckers’ enhancements on this quote?
  • Which cargo form and limits are offered, and do they meet my broker contracts?
  • Which additional insured endorsements are included, and do they match my contracts’ wording?
  • What are the deductibles for physical damage, cargo and property, and is a combined deductible available?

How it fits with getting several quotes

Acuity sells through independent agents, so it is normally quoted next to other carriers rather than on its own. Rates and appetite differ a lot between insurers for the same truck or trade, especially in trucking. Comparing two or three quotes with the same limits, deductibles and endorsements shows where the real differences are.

A broker such as Florin can compare quotes from several insurers for your business. Before you bind any policy, make sure the carrier is licensed in your state.

Frequently asked questions

Is Acuity Insurance a legitimate insurance company?

Yes. Acuity, A Mutual Insurance Company, was incorporated in Wisconsin in 1925, and the Wisconsin Office of the Commissioner of Insurance regulates it. That office examined the company as of December 31, 2024. Acuity’s site shows an A+ rating from AM Best dated February 6, 2026.

Who owns Acuity Insurance?

Its policyholders own it. Acuity is a mutual insurer with no stockholders, and its headquarters is in Sheboygan, Wisconsin.

Can I buy Acuity business insurance online?

You can start a business quote on Acuity’s website, but most policies are sold and serviced through independent agents. The Wisconsin OCI also notes a digital agency subsidiary, Acuity Advantage Insurance Agency, that either sells Acuity products directly or refers customers to other carriers.

Does Acuity insure owner-operators?

Yes. Acuity’s trucking page says it insures large fleets as well as owner-operators. It offers bobtail or deadhead coverage for tractors driven without a trailer or with an empty one.

Will Acuity make my FMCSA insurance filings?

Acuity says it makes the federal and state filings a trucking operation needs, including financial responsibility and cargo filings. To confirm a filing is active, check your record in the FMCSA system after the policy starts.

Does Acuity write insurance in California or Florida?

Neither state is among the 38 where the Wisconsin OCI listed Acuity as licensed in its 2025 report. A business there needs a carrier licensed in its state.

Facts are drawn from the providers’ own published information and other cited sources as of the date above, and may change. Florin is an independent brokerage; this page is not an endorsement or a rating of any insurer.

← All provider reviews